Exploring concomitant concepts in the discussion on the circular economy: A bibliometric analysis of Web of Science, Scopus and Twitter


A growing interest in the circular economy, which is seen in the intensification of public discourse, could lead to a danger of blurring the concept and introducing inefficiency in implementing circular economy-based solutions. This study explores the trend in concomitant or accompanying concepts of the discussion about the circular economy themes understanding regarding scientific publications (3,486 publications from Web of Science and Scopus) and popular (non-scientific) domain (represented by 106,504 tweets) in the years 2011–2018. By employing text mining, we calculated the Jaccard similarity index divided into years. The results reveal changes over time in themes accompanying the circular economy discussion and a trend of rising recognition of research-related keywords in general public discussion, with unweighted similarity reaching 39.44% in 2018. Our Twitter keyword research perspective indicates the need to consider the consumer’s role in the development of the circular economy – through keywords that are closely related to consumers’ daily activities.

Keyword : circular economy, sustainable development, concepts meaning, bibliometrics, Twitter

How to Cite
Mirzyńska, A., Kosch, O., Schieg, M., Šuhajda, K., & Szarucki, M. (2021). Exploring concomitant concepts in the discussion on the circular economy: A bibliometric analysis of Web of Science, Scopus and Twitter. Technological and Economic Development of Economy, 27(6), 1539-1562.
Published in Issue
Nov 18, 2021
Abstract Views
PDF Downloads
Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.


Albino, V., & Fraccascia, L. (2015). The Industrial Symbiosis approach: A classification of business models. Procedia Environmental Science, Engineering and Management, 2(3), 217–223.

Andersen, M. S. (2007). An introductory note on the environmental economics of the circular economy. Sustainability Science, 2(1), 133–140.

Araujo Galvão, G. D., De Nadae, J., Clemente, D. H., Chinen, G., & De Carvalho, M. M. (2018). Circular economy: Overview of barriers. Proce-dia CIRP, 73, 79–85.

Aria, M., & Cuccurullo, C. (2017). bibliometrix: An R-tool for comprehensive science mapping analysis. Journal of Informetrics, 11(4), 959–975.

Bansal, P., Bansal, R., & Varma, V. (2015). Towards deep semantic analysis of hashtags. In A. Hanbury, G. Kazai, A. Rauber, & N. Fuhr (Eds.), Lecture notes in computer science: Vol. 9022. Advances in information retrieval (pp. 453–464). Springer.

Boons, F., & Lüdeke-Freund, F. (2013). Business models for sustainable innovation: State-of-the-art and steps towards a research agenda. Journal of Cleaner Production, 45, 9–19.

Bornmann, L. (2015). Alternative metrics in scientometrics: A meta-analysis of research into three altmetrics. Scientometrics, 103(3), 1123–1144.

Boulding, K. E. (1966). The economics of the coming spaceship earth. In H. Jarrett (Ed.), Environmental quality in a growing economy, resources for the future (pp. 3–14). Johns Hopkins University Press.

Bramer, W. M., Rethlefsen, M. L., Kleijnen, J., & Franco, O. H. (2017). Optimal database combinations for literature searches in systematic re-views: A prospective exploratory study. Systematic Reviews, 6(1), 245.

Braz, A. C., De Mello, A. M., de Vasconcelos Gomes, L. A., & de Souza Nascimento, P. T. (2018). The bullwhip effect in closed-loop supply chains: A systematic literature review. Journal of Cleaner Production, 202, 376–389.

Budak, C., Agrawal, D., & El Abbadi, A. (2011). Structural trend analysis for online social networks. Proceedings of the VLDB Endowment, 4(10), 646–656.

Cannella, A. A., & Paetzold, R. L. (1994). PFEFFER’S barriers to the advance of organizational science: A rejoinder. Academy of Management Review, 19(2), 331–341.

Çelebi, A., & Ozgür, A. (2016). Segmenting hashtags using automatically created training data. In Proceedings of the 10th International Conference on Language Resources and Evaluation, LREC 2016 (pp. 2981–2985).

Chang, H. C., & Iyer, H. (2012). Trends in Twitter hashtag applications: Design features for value-added dimensions to future library catalogues. Library Trends, 61(1), 248–258.

Chen, C. (2006). CiteSpace II: Detecting and visualizing emerging trends and transient patterns in scientific literature. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 57(3), 359–377.

Ciliberto, C., Szopik-Depczyńska, K., Tarczyńska-Łuniewska, M., Ruggieri, A., & Ioppolo, G. (2021). Enabling the Circular Economy transition: A sustainable lean manufacturing recipe for Industry 4.0. Business Strategy and the Environment, 1–18.

Commoner, B. (1971). The closing circle: Nature, man, and technology. Random House.

Cui, T., & Zhang, J. (2018). Bibliometric and review of the research on circular economy through the evolution of Chinese public policy. Scien-tometrics, 116(2), 1013–1037.

D’Amato, D., Droste, N., Allen, B., Kettunen, M., Lähtinen, K., Korhonen, J., Leskinen, P., Matthies, B. D., & Toppinen, A. (2017). Green, circu-lar, bio economy: A comparative analysis of sustainability avenues. Journal of Cleaner Production, 168, 716–734.

Dahlsrud, A. (2008). How corporate social responsibility is defined: An analysis of 37 definitions. Corporate Social Responsibility and Environ-mental Management, 15(1), 1–13.

de Jesus, A., & Mendonça, S. (2018). Lost in transition? Drivers and barriers in the eco-innovation road to the circular economy. Ecological Eco-nomics, 145, 75–89.

de Pascale, A., Arbolino, R., Szopik-Depczyńska, K., Limosani, M., & Ioppolo, G. (2021). A systematic review for measuring circular economy: The 61 indicators. Journal of Cleaner Production, 281, 124942.

de Vries, B. J. M., & Petersen, A. C. (2009). Conceptualizing sustainable development. An assessment methodology connecting values, knowledge, worldviews and scenarios. Ecological Economics, 68(4), 1006–1019.

Deus, R. M., Savietto, J. P., Battistelle, R. A. G., & Ometto, A. R. (2017). Trends in publications on the circular economy. Espacios, 38(58), 20.

Diaz Lopez, F. J., Bastein, T., & Tukker, A. (2019). Business model innovation for resource-efficiency, circularity and cleaner production: What 143 cases tell us. Ecological Economics, 155, 20–35.

Eitzel, M. V., Cappadonna, J. L., Santos-Lang, C., Duerr, R. E., Virapongse, A., West, S. E., Kyba, Ch. C. M., Bowser, A., Cooper, C. B., Sfor-zi, A., Metcalfe, A. N., Harris, E. S., Thiel, M., Haklay, M., Ponciano, L., Roche, J., Ceccaroni, L., Shilling, F. M., Dörler, D., Heigl, F., Kiessling, T., Davis, B. Y., & Jiang, Q. (2017). Citizen science terminology matters: Exploring key terms. Citizen Science: Theory and Practice, 2(1), 1–20.

Engelman, R. (2013). Beyond sustainababble. In Worldwatch Institute (Eds.), State of the World 2013 (pp. 3–16). Island Press.

Fraccascia, L., Giannoccaro, I., & Albino, V. (2019). Business models for industrial symbiosis: A taxonomy focused on the form of governance. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 146, 114–126.

Gallie, W. B. (1956). Essentially contested concepts. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 56(1), 167–198.

Geissdoerfer, M., Pieroni, M. P. P., Pigosso, D. C. A., & Soufani, K. (2020). Circular business models: A review. Journal of Cleaner Production, 277, 123741.

Geissdoerfer, M., Savaget, P., Bocken, N. M. P., & Hultink, E. J. (2017). The Circular Economy – A new sustainability paradigm? Journal of Cleaner Production, 143, 757–768.

Ghisellini, P., Cialani, C., & Ulgiati, S. (2016). A review on circular economy: The expected transition to a balanced interplay of environmental and economic systems. Journal of Cleaner Production, 114, 11–32.

Gieryn, T. F. (1997). Boundaries of science. In A. I. Tauber (Ed.), Science and the quest for reality. Main trends of the modern world (pp. 293–332). Palgrave Macmillan.

Gladek, E. (2017). The seven pillars of the circular economy – From linear to circular.

Gregorio, V. F., Pié, L., & Terceño, A. (2018). A systematic literature review of bio, green and circular economy trends in publications in the field of economics and business management. Sustainability, 10(11), 4232.

Haustein, S., Peters, I., Sugimoto, C. R., Thelwall, M., & Larivière, V. (2014). Tweeting biomedicine: An analysis of tweets and citations in the biomedical literature. Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 65(4), 656–669.

Heshmati, A. (2017). A review of the circular economy and its implementation. International Journal of Green Economics, 11(3–4), 251–288.

Hingle, M., Yoon, D., Fowler, J., Kobourov, S., Schneider, M. L., Falk, D., & Burd, R. (2013). Collection and visualization of dietary behavior and reasons for eating using twitter. Journal of Medical Internet Research, 15(6), e125.

Holmberg, K., & Thelwall, M. (2014). Disciplinary differences in Twitter scholarly communication. Scientometrics, 101(2), 1027–1042.

Homrich, A. S., Galvão, G., Abadia, L. G., & Carvalho, M. M. (2018). The circular economy umbrella: Trends and gaps on integrating pathways. Journal of Cleaner Production, 175, 525–543.

Horvath, B., Khazami, N., Ymeri, P., & Fogarassy, C. (2019). Investigating the current business model innovation trends in the biotechnology industry. Journal of Business Economics and Management, 20(1), 63–85.

Huang, L., Clarke, A., Heldsinger, N., & Tian, W. (2019). The communication role of social media in social marketing: A study of the community sustainability knowledge dissemination on LinkedIn and Twitter. Journal of Marketing Analytics, 7(2), 64–75.

Jabbour, C. J. C., Fiorini, P. D. C., Ndubisi, N. O., Queiroz, M. M., & Piato, É. L. (2020). Digitally-enabled sustainable supply chains in the 21st century: A review and a research agenda. Science of the Total Environment, 725, 138177.

Janoušková, S., Hák, T., Nečas, V., & Moldan, B. (2019). Sustainable development – A poorly communicated concept by mass media. Another challenge for SDG. Sustainability, 11(11), 3181.

Ji, L., Liu, C., Huang, L., & Huang, G. (2018). The evolution of Resources Conservation and Recycling over the past 30 years: A bibliometric overview. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 134, 34–43.

Jin, R., Yuan, H., & Chen, Q. (2019). Science mapping approach to assisting the review of construction and demolition waste management research published between 2009 and 2018. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 140, 175–188.

Johnston, R. B. (2016). Arsenic and the 2030 agenda for sustainable development. In Arsenic Research and Global Sustainability. Proceedings of the 6th International Congress on Arsenic in the Environment (As 2016) (pp. 12–14).

Kearney, M. W. (2018). rtweet: Collecting Twitter Data.

Khan, I. S., Ahmad, M. O., & Majava, J. (2021, May 15). Industry 4.0 and sustainable development: A systematic mapping of triple bottom line, Circular Economy and Sustainable Business Models perspectives. Journal of Cleaner Production, 297, 126655.

Kirchherr, J., Reike, D., & Hekkert, M. (2017). Conceptualizing the circular economy: An analysis of 114 definitions. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 127, 221–232.

Korhonen, J., Honkasalo, A., & Seppälä, J. (2018a). Circular economy: The concept and its limitations. Ecological Economics, 143, 37–46.

Korhonen, J., Nuur, C., Feldmann, A., & Birkie, S. E. (2018b) Circular economy as an essentially contested concept. Journal of Cleaner Produc-tion, 175, 544–552.

Latour, B. (1987). Science in action: How to follow scientists and engineers through society. Harvard University Press.

Lewis, E. L., & Linn, M. C. (1996). Where is the heat? A response to David Pushkin. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 33(3), 335–337.

Lieder, M., & Rashid, A. (2016). Towards circular economy implementation: A comprehensive review in context of manufacturing industry. Jour-nal of Cleaner Production, 115, 36–51.

Lifset, R., & Graedel, T. E. (2015). Industrial ecology. In J. D. Wright (Ed.), International encyclopedia of the social & behavioral sciences (2nd ed., pp. 843–853). Elsevier.

Lindenfeld, L. A., Hall, D. M., McGreavy, B., Silka, L., & Hart, D. (2012). Creating a place for environmental communication research in sustain-ability science. Environmental Communication, 6(1), 23–43.

Loiseau, E., Saikku, L., Antikainen, R., Droste, N., Hansjürgens, B., Pitkänen, K., Leskinen, P., Kuikman, P., & Thomsen, M. (2016). Green economy and related concepts: An overview. Journal of Cleaner Production, 139, 361–371.

Lopes de Sousa Jabbour, A. B., Jabbour, C. J. C., Godinho Filho, M., & Roubaud, D. (2018). Industry 4.0 and the circular economy: A proposed research agenda and original roadmap for sustainable operations. Annals of Operations Research, 270(1–2), 273–286.

Lüdeke-Freund, F., Gold, S., & Bocken, N. M. P. (2019). A review and typology of circular economy business model patterns. Journal of Indus-trial Ecology, 23(1), 36–61.

Lyle, J. T. (1996). Regenerative design for sustainable development. John Wiley & Sons.

Magrí, A., Giovannini, F., Connan, R., Bridoux, G., & Béline, F. (2017). Nutrient management from biogas digester effluents: A biblio-metric-based analysis of publications and patents. International Journal of Environmental Science and Technology, 14(8), 1739–1756.

McDonough, W., & Braungart, M. (2002). Cradle to cradle: Remaking the way we make things. North Point Press.

McDowall, W., Geng, Y., Huang, B., Barteková, E., Bleischwitz, R., Türkeli, S., Kemp, R., & Doménech, T. (2017). Circular economy policies in China and Europe. Journal of Industrial Ecology, 21(3), 651–661.

Michelini, G., Moraes, R. N., Cunha, R. N., Costa, J. M. H., & Ometto, A. R. (2017). From linear to circular economy: PSS conducting the transi-tion. Procedia CIRP, 64, 2–6.

Moya-Clemente, I., Ribes-Giner, G., & Chaves-Vargas, J. C. (2021). Sustainable entrepreneurship: An approach from bibliometric analysis. Jour-nal of Business Economics and Management, 22(2), 297–319.

Mullen, L., Benoit, K., Keyes, O., Selivanov, D., & Arnold, J. (2018). Fast, consistent tokenization of natural language text. Journal of Open Source Software, 3(23), 655.

Naudé, M. (2011). Sustainable development in companies: Theoretical dream or implementable reality? Corporate Ownership and Control, 8(4), 352–364.

Nobre, G. C., & Tavares, E. (2017). Scientific literature analysis on big data and internet of things applications on circular economy: A bibliometric study. Scientometrics, 111(1), 463–492.

Pauli, G. (2010). The blue economy: 10 years, 100 innovations, 100 million jobs. Paradigm Publications.

Pfeffer, J. (1993). Barriers to the advance of organizational science: Paradigm development as a dependent variable. Academy of Management Re-view, 18(4), 599–620.

Priem, J. (2014). Altmetrics. In B. Cronin & C. R. Sugimoto (Eds.), Beyond bibliometrics: Harnessing multidimensional indicators of scholarly impact (pp. 263–288). The MIT Press.

Priem, J., & Costello, K. L. (2010). How and why scholars cite on Twitter. Proceedings of the ASIST Annual Meeting, 47(1), 1–4.

Priem, J., Piwowar, H. A., & Hemminger, B. M. (2012, March 20). Altmetrics in the wild: Using social media to explore scholarly impact.

Pulgarín, A. (2012). Dependence of Lotka’s law parameters on the scientific area. Malaysian Journal of Library and Information Science, 17(1), 41–50.

Pushkin, D. B. (1996). A comment on the need to use scientific terminology appropriately in conception studies. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 33(2), 223–224.

R Development Core Team. (2018). R: A language and environment for statistical computing.

Rajput, S., & Singh, S. P. (2019). Connecting circular economy and industry 4.0. International Journal of Information Management, 49, 98–113.

Rajput, S., & Singh, S. P. (2020). Industry 4.0 model for circular economy and cleaner production. Journal of Cleaner Production, 277, 123853.

Reuter, J., Pereira-Martins, J., & Kalita, J. (2016). Segmenting Twitter hashtags. International Journal on Natural Language Computing, 5(4), 23–36.

Richardson, J., Grose, J., Nelmes, P., Parra, G., & Linares, M. (2016). Tweet if you want to be sustainable: A thematic analysis of a Twitter chat to discuss sustainability in nurse education. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 72(5), 1086–1096.

Ruiz-Real, J. L., Uribe-Toril, J., Valenciano, J. D. P., & Gázquez-Abad, J. C. (2018). Worldwide research on circular economy and environment: A bibliometric analysis. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 15(12), 2699.

Russell-Rose, T., Lamantia, J., & Makri, S. (2014). Defining and applying a language for discovery. In A. Nürnberger, S. Stober, B. Larsen, & M. Detyniecki (Eds.), Lecture notes in computer science, Vol. 8382. Adaptive multimedia retrieval: Semantics, context, and adaptation (pp. 3–28). Springer.

Saavedra, Y. M. B., Iritani, D. R., Pavan, A. L. R., & Ometto, A. R. (2018). Theoretical contribution of industrial ecology to circular economy. Journal of Cleaner Production, 170, 1514–1522.

Sager, J. C. (1990). A practical course in terminology processing. John Benjamins Publishing Company.

Sartori, S., da Silva, F., & Campos, L. M. S. (2011). Sustainability and sustainable development: A taxonomy in the field of literature. Ambiente & Sociedade, 17(1), 1–22.

Schroeder, P., Anggraeni, K., & Weber, U. (2019). The relevance of circular economy practices to the sustainable development goals. Journal of Industrial Ecology, 23(1), 77–95.

Segerson, K., Pearce, D. W., & Turner, R. K. (1991). Economics of natural resources and the environment. Land Economics, 67(2), 272–276.

Selivanov, D., & Wang, Q. (2018). text2vec: Modern text mining framework for R.

Shahzalal, M., & Hassan, A. (2019). Communicating sustainability: Using community media to influence rural people’s intention to adopt sustaina-ble behaviour. Sustainability, 11(3), 812.

Sharmila, S. P., & Sujatha, P. K. (2016). Segmentation based representation for tweet hashtag. In 2015 7th International Conference on Advanced Computing (ICoAC) (pp. 1–7). Chennai, India. IEEE.

Shen, K. W., Li, L., & Wang, J. Q. (2020). Circular economy model for recycling waste resources under government participation: A case study in industrial waste water circulation in China. Technological and Economic Development of Economy, 26(1), 21–47.

Stahel, W. R. (2010). The performance economy. Palgrave Macmillan.

Stankevičienė, J., & Nikanorova, M. (2020). Eco-innovation as a pillar for sustainable development of circular economy. Business: Theory and Practice, 21(2), 531–544.

Su, B., Heshmati, A., Geng, Y., & Yu, X. (2013). A review of the circular economy in China: Moving from rhetoric to implementation. Journal of Cleaner Production, 42, 215–227.

Temmerman, R. (2000). Towards new ways of terminology description: The sociocognitive approach. John Benjamins Publishing Company.

Thelwall, M., Haustein, S., Larivière, V., & Sugimoto, C. R. (2013). Do altmetrics work? Twitter and ten other social web services. PLoS ONE, 8(5), e64841.

Todeschini, R., & Baccini, A. (2016). Handbook of bibliometric indicators: Quantitative tools for studying and evaluating research. Wiley-VCH.

Torres-Salinas, D., Cabezas-Clavijo, Á., & Jiménez-Contreras, E. (2013). Altmetrics: New indicators for scientific communication in Web 2.0. Comunicar, 21(41), 53–60.

Tseng, M. L., Tan, R. R., Chiu, A. S. F., Chien, C. F., & Kuo, T. C. (2018). Circular economy meets industry 4.0: Can big data drive industrial symbiosis? Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 131, 146–147.

Türkeli, S., Kemp, R., Huang, B., Bleischwitz, R., & McDowall, W. (2018). Circular economy scientific knowledge in the European Union and China: A bibliometric, network and survey analysis (2006–2016). Journal of Cleaner Production, 197, 1244–1261.

van Eck, N. J., & Waltman, L. (2010). Software survey: VOSviewer, a computer program for bibliometric mapping. Scientometrics, 84(2), 523–538.

Veltri, G. A., & Atanasova, D. (2017). Climate change on Twitter: Content, media ecology and information sharing behaviour. Public Understand-ing of Science, 26(6), 721–737.

Weller, K., Dröge, E., & Puschmann, C. (2011). Citation analysis in Twitter: Approaches for defining and measuring information flows within tweets during scientific conferences. CEUR Workshop Proceedings, 718, 1–12.

Wijffels, J. (2018). udpipe: Tokenization, parts of speech tagging, lemmatization and dependency parsing with the “UDPipe” “NLP” Toolkit.

Yazan, D. M., & Fraccascia, L. (2019). Sustainable operations of industrial symbiosis: An enterprise input-output model integrated by agent-based simulation. International Journal of Production Research, 58(2), 392–414.

Yuan, Z., Bi, J., & Moriguichi, Y. (2006). The circular economy: A new development strategy in China. Journal of Industrial Ecology, 10(1–2), 4–8.