Wheel–rail wear investigation on a heavy haul balloon loop track through simulations of slow speed wagon dynamics

    Yan Quan Sun Affiliation
    ; Maksym Spiryagin Affiliation
    ; Colin Cole Affiliation
    ; Dwayne Nielsen Affiliation


Heavy haul railway track infrastructure are commonly equipped with balloon loops to allow trains to be loaded/unloaded and/or to reverse the direction of travel. The slow operational speed of trains on these sharp curves results in some unique issues regarding the wear process between wheels and rails. A wagon dynamic system model has been applied to simulate the dynamic behaviour in order to study the wheel–rail contact wear conditions. A wheel– rail wear index is used to assess the wear severity. The simulation shows that the lubrication to reduce the wheel–rail contact friction coefficient can significantly reduce the wear severity. Furthermore, the effects of important parameters on wheel–rail contact wear including curve radius, wagon speed and track superelevation have also been considered.

Keyword : balloon loop track, wagon dynamics, wheel–rail wear index, simulation

How to Cite
Sun, Y. Q., Spiryagin, M., Cole, C., & Nielsen, D. (2017). Wheel–rail wear investigation on a heavy haul balloon loop track through simulations of slow speed wagon dynamics. Transport, 33(3), 843-852.
Published in Issue
Sep 4, 2017
Abstract Views
PDF Downloads
Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.


ARTC. 2015. Track Geometry. Australian Rail Track Corporation (ARTC), Australia.

Braghin, F.; Lewis, R.; Dwyer-Joyce, R. S.; Bruni, S. 2006. A mathematical model to predict railway wheel profile evolution due to wear, Wear 261(11–12): 1253–1264.

Chiddick, K. S.; Eadie, D. T. 1999. Wheel/rail friction management solutions, in 14th International Conference on Current Problems in Rail Vehicles: PRORAIL 99, 6–8 October 1999, Žilina, Slovakia.

Cuervo, P. A.; Santa, J. F; Toro, A. 2015. Correlations between wear mechanisms and rail grinding operations in a commercial railroad, Tribology International 82: 265–273.

DEsolver. 2017. GENSYS.1609 Reference Manual. AB DEsolver, Östersund, Sweden. Available from Internet:

Donzella, G.; Faccoli, M.; Ghidini, A.; Mazzù, A.; Roberti, R. 2005. The competitive role of wear and RCF in a rail steel, Engineering Fracture Mechanics 72(2): 287–308.

Dukkipati, R. V.; Swamy, S. N. 2001. Non-linear steady-state curving analysis of some unconventional rail trucks, Mechanism and Machine Theory 36(4): 507–521.

EMRAILS. 2016. 60 kg Rail. EMRAILS: The Australian Rail Stockist, Victoria, Australia. Available from Internet:

ESR 0332:2010. WPR 2000 Wheel Profile. Engineering Standard, Rolling Stock, Australia. 8 p. Available from Internet:

Harvey, R. F.; McEwen, I. J. 1986. The Relationship between Wear Number and Wheel/Rail Wear in the Laboratory and the Field. British Rail Research Report TM-VDY-001.

He, C.-G.; Zhou, G.-Y.; Wang, J.; Wen, G.; Wang, W.-J.;
Liu, Q.-Y. 2014. Effect of curve radius of rail on rolling contact fatigue properties of wheel steel, Tribology 34(3): 257–261. (in Chinese).

Hernández, F. C. R.; Demas, N. G.; Davis, D. D.; Polycarpou, A. A.; Maal, L. 2007. Mechanical properties and wear performance of premium rail steels, Wear 263(1–6): 766–772.

Ishida, M.; Aoki, F. 2004. Effect of lubrication on vehicle/track interaction, Quarterly Report of RTRI 45(3): 131–135.

Johansson, A.; Pålsson, B.; Ekh, M.; Nielsen, J. C. O.; Ander, M. K. A.; Brouzoulis, J.; Kassa, E. 2011. Simulation of wheel–rail contact and damage in switches & crossings, Wear 271(1–2): 472–481.

Pearce, T. G.; Sherratt, N. D. 1991. Prediction of wheel profile wear, Wear 144(1–2): 343–351.

Pombo, J.; Ambrósio, J.; Pereira, M.; Lewis, R.; Dwyer-Joyce, R.; Ariaudo, C.; Kuka, N. 2011. Development of a wear prediction tool for steel railway wheels using three alternative wear functions, Wear 271(1–2): 238–245.

Remennikov, A. M.; Kaewunruen, S. 2008. A review of loading conditions for railway track structures due to train and track vertical interaction, Structural Control and Health Monitoring 15(2): 207–234.

Resonate Group Ltd. 2016. VAMPIRE® User Manual. Resonate Group Limited, Derby, UK. Available from Internet:

Shevtsov, I. Y.; Markine, V. L.; Esveld, C. 2005. Optimal design of wheel profile for railway vehicles, Wear 258(7–8): 1022–1030.

Spiryagin, M.; Sajjad, M.; Nielsen, D.; Sun, Y. Q.; Raman, D.; Chattopadhyay, G. 2014. Research methodology for evaluation of top-of-rail friction management in Australian heavy haul networks, Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part F: Journal of Rail and Rapid Transit 228(6): 631–641.

Spiryagin, M.; Wolfs, P.; Cole, C.; Spiryagin, V.; Sun, Y. Q.; McSweeney, T. 2016. Design and Simulation of Heavy Haul Locomotives and Trains. CRC Press. 459 p.

Sun, Y. Q.; Cole, C.; Dhanasekar, M.; Thambiratnam, D. P. 2012. Modelling and analysis of the crush zone of a typical Australian passenger train, Vehicle System Dynamics: International Journal of Vehicle Mechanics and Mobility 50(7): 1137–1155.

Sun, Y. Q.; Simson, S. 2008. Wagon–track modelling and parametric study on rail corrugation initiation due to wheel stick-slip process on curved track, Wear 265(9–10): 1193–1201.

Sun, Y. Q.; Spiryagin, M.; Simson, S.; Cole, C. R.; Kreiser, D. 2011. Adequacy of modelling of friction wedge suspensions in three-piece bogies, in IAVSD 2011: 22nd International Symposium on Dynamics of Vehicles on Roads and Tracks, 14–19 August 2011, Manchester, UK, 1–6.

Tao, G.; Wang, H.; Zhao, X.; Du, X.; Wen, Z.; Guo, J.; Zhu, M. 2013. Research on wheel tread damage mechanism based on interaction of wheel and rail, Journal of Mechanical Engineering: 49(18): 23–29. (in Chinese).

Tassini, N.; Quost, X.; Lewis, R.; Dwyer-Joyce, R.; Ariaudo, C.; Kuka, N. 2010. A numerical model of twin disc test arrangement for the evaluation of railway wheel wear prediction methods, Wear 268(5–6): 660–667.

Telliskivi, T.; Olofsson, U. 2004. Wheel–rail wear simulation, Wear 257(11): 1145–1153.

Torstensson, P. T.; Nielsen, J. C. O. 2011. Simulation of dynamic vehicle–track interaction on small radius curves, Vehicle System Dynamics: International Journal of Vehicle Mechanics and Mobility 49(11): 1711–1732.

Waara, P.; Norrby, T.; Prakash, B. 2004, Tribochemical wear of rail steels lubricated with synthetic ester-based model lubricants, Tribology Letters 17(3): 561–568.

Wang, K.; Huang, C.; Zhai, W.; Liu, P.; Wang, S. 2014. Progress on wheel–rail dynamic performance of railway curve negotiation, Journal of Traffic and Transportation Engineering (English Edition) 1(3): 209–220.

Zakharov, S.; Zharov, I. 2002. Simulation of mutual wheel/rail wear, Wear 253(1–2): 100–106.

Zhai, W.; Gao, J.; Liu, P.; Wang, K. 2014. Reducing rail side wear on heavy-haul railway curves based on wheel–rail dynamic interaction, Vehicle System Dynamics: International Journal of Vehicle Mechanics and Mobility 52(Suppl 1): 440–454.